Image Map E-Mail ASAA Contact ASAA ASAA Membership Form Return to Home Page Amateur Archaeologist Online Journal
Open Letter to Prospective Members
Origin of Society's Symbol
Calendar of Archaeological Expeditions
Previous Fieldwork Location and Dates
The Society's Journal
Back Issues of the Society's Journal
The Amatuer Archaeologist Online Journal
The Amatuer Archaeologist Space
Other Archaeological Publications Available Through ASAA
Authors
ASAA Shop
Book Reviews
Photo Montage of ASAA Excavations and Discoveries
Associated Chapters and Lifetime Members
Join Yahoo Group Amateur Archaeology
Favorite Links

COPYRIGHT NOTICE/DISCLAIMER

This Page has been updated! If you are a return visitor you will need to reload/refresh your browser in order to see any new content.

THE AMATEUR ARCHAEOLOGIST ONLINE

Click here to download document a_remarkable_clovis_point_from_upper_cross_creek.doc for printing.

A REMARKABLE CLOVIS POINT FROM UPPER CROSS CREEK, WASHINGTON COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA

(A version of this paper appeared in Volume 30 (3), pp. 3-6 of Indian Artifact Magazine, August 2011)

Richard Michael Gramly PhD
North Andover, Massachusetts

Amateur Archaeologist JournalOn April 28, 2010, John Zylo and Jim Krajacic, residents of Washington County, southwestern Pennsylvania, were hunting for artifacts in cultivated fields along Cross Creek east of the town of Avella and north of Buffalo in Washington County (Figure 1). Entering a field, which for many years had lain fallow, on the Moore family farm along Lynn Portal Road (Figure 2), Mr. Zylo was fortunate to discover a complete Clovis point that had been freshly exposed by a deep furrow.

Amateur Archaeologist JournalThe region where this find was made is cris-crossed by many small streams flowing into Cross Creek, which is itself a tributary of the Ohio River. Small, surficial lithic scatters abound in this part of the maturely-dissected, unglaciated Allegheny Plateau. Hundreds of them have been recorded in the immediate region during archaeological reconnoitering (Fryman 1982) by the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Museum.

Jump link: Figures and Captions

Amateur Archaeologist JournalIn the immediate vicinity of the Moore farm there have been a few discoveries of Clovis points — only one of which, it seems, has been reported and described (Lowery et al. 2007). At least 12, but perhaps as many as 21 other fluted points are known for Washington County (Fogelman and Lantz 2006). This tally seems about average (median) for all the counties in Pennsylvania.

Amateur Archaeologist Journal

Amateur Archaeologist JournalSeveral miles west of the Moore farm and downstream of it within the Cross Creek valley is the well-known Meadowcroft Rockshelter (Adovasio et al. 1975; Adovasio et al. 1977). A small assemblage of Palaeo-American flaked stone artifacts has been described from Stratum IIa at this site, which is dated to the interval 11,300 to 12,800 radiocarbon years before present plus a large standard deviation (Gramly and Funk 1990: 6). Conceivably this assemblage was left at the rockshelter by Clovis visitors or an even older "pre-Clovis" group.

The Zylo Clovis Point
Amateur Archaeologist JournalWhat is noteworthy about this artifact is not its size (see Table) but rather the fact it had never been resharpened. Pristine Clovis points are seldom found — for example, there was only one specimen among 175 fluted and unfluted bifaces at the Vail site, Maine (Gramly 2009) — and when authentic, single specimens become known, usually they are interpreted as accidental losses or elements of a cache.

Amateur Archaeologist JournalThe Zylo point exhibits outrepasse flaking on both of its faces (see Figure 3), which is a hallmark of Clovis technology. Edge-work is very fine and has resulted in a sleek, regularly tapered form. The fluting scars are relatively short, which may be a result of the jointed raw material that was used to make this point. This rock closely resembles Bellefonte (also known as Belleville) Chalcedony, which outcrops in Centre County, Pennsylvania — a full 200 km ENE of Washington County.

Amateur Archaeologist JournalBellefonte Chalcedony is characterized by jointing, iron mineralization, translucency in thin pieces, and a clear to dark gray color. It is known to have been employed by Clovis knappers. Since the Zylo Clovis point (Figures 4 and 5) shares these attributes with hand-specimens from the actual type locality (on file at the Holland Lithic Laboratory, Buffalo Museum of Science, Buffalo, New York), it is tempting to attribute the artifact to that specific source. Caution is advisable, however, as nearly identical raw material is known to occur within the Schreiber Formation, Kisquillis valley, near Penn's Creek, central Pennsylvania (Tim Jackson, Tyrone, PA — personal communication).

Amateur Archaeologist JournalWhatever its exact source, it seems likely that the raw material from which Zylo point was made originated in Pennsylvania.

Jump link: Figures and Captions

A Visit to the Find-spot and Test-excavating
Amateur Archaeologist JournalAfter the authenticity of the Clovis point had been confirmed by David Walley using an infrared laser spectrograph (David Walley, personal communication, August 23, 2010), it was sent to Jim Chase at DUP-LA-CAST for casting. Four copies were made, and one of them was sent to artist Steve Wallmann for the illustration that is reproduced here (Figure 3).

Amateur Archaeologist JournalWhile this work with the Zylo Clovis point was being done, permission was sought from the property owner for archaeological testing of the find-spot. It was granted, and a visit to the Moore farm (Figure 6) was made on October 24, 2010 — a time after harvest when the field was available for trenching. We intended to excavate as deep as the base of the tilth zone in search of other Clovis specimens. Although I felt that the point once may have lain within a cache, it was equally plausible that the artifact marked a small habitation site. In such a case, the point might have been a loss — surely an uncommon occurrence.

Amateur Archaeologist JournalDespite wet conditions our small field-crew was able to shovel and trowel four 2-m squares at the intersection of two narrow trenches. A careful watch was kept for subsoil features that might have produced artifacts. Our trenches totaled 23 meters in length and were positioned at right angles to one another. The intersection of the trenches was thought to be the exact find-spot of the Clovis point.

Jump link: Figures and Captions

Amateur Archaeologist JournalInteresting to note, the sole Palaeo-American artifact that was recovered during our testing lay at the intersection! It is a biface reduction flake with a graver spur at one of its corners — a fortuitous projection that was enhanced by fine, unifacial flaking (Figure 7). The raw material of the tool is dense black chert without jointing. It closely resembles black Kanawha or Coshocton chert of Pennsylvanian age and may have originated a long distance west of the Moore farm on Cross Creek. There is also a possibility that the raw material was obtained closer at hand along Buffalo Creek, which lies immediately north of the Cross Creek drainage (Bill Tippins, personal communication). Confirmation that this local source was exploited during the Palaeo-American era, however, is wanting.

Amateur Archaeologist JournalSince the plowed soil very quickly turned to mud on our sieves, we were unable to recover any fine flaked stone debitage. Such debitage might have confirmed that the Zylo Clovis point and associated graver were deposited at a small, briefly occupied Palaeo-American encampment. The idea that the point was cached does not seem to be plausible — given the evidence (or lack of it). Although no additional Clovis bifaces came to light during our testing, we were satisfied that our effort had been commensurate with the importance of John Zylo's remarkable find.

Acknowledgments
Amateur Archaeologist Journal I wish to thank Jim Krajacic, John Zylo and Dan Morgan for their labor in the field and other kind favors. Also, through the good offices of Jack Holland I was able to access lithic reference materials among the collections of the Buffalo Museum of Science, Buffalo, N.Y.

Amateur Archaeologist Journal

Amateur Archaeologist Journal

Amateur Archaeologist Journal

Table. Attributes of the Zylo Clovis Point

Length = 111.0 mm
Maximum width = 31.3 mm
Maximum thickness = 9.1 mm
Weight (in grams) = 37.8
Length of channel flake (Side A) = 18.3 mm
Amateur Archaeologist Journal(Note: Flake is terminated by step fracture)
Length of channel flake (Side B) = 18.3 mm
Amateur Archaeologist Journal(Note: Flake is terminated by a step fracture)
Depth of basal concavity = 4.4 mm
Grinding is present within the basal concavity and as high as 33 mm along the sides, as measured upward from the ears.

References Cited


Adovasio, J. M., J. D. Gunn, J. Donahue, and R. Stuckenrath
1982Amateur Archaeologist Journal
Pp. 53-68 in R. C. Carlisle and J. M. Adovasio (eds.)Collected Papers on the Archaeology of Meadowcroft Rockshelter and the Cross Creek Drainage. Cultural Resource Management Program, University of Pittsburgh. (Fourth printing, `275 pp.)

Gramly, Richard M. (editor)
2009Amateur Archaeologist Journal
Palaeo-Americans and Palaeo-Environment at the Vail Site, Maine. Persimmon Press. North Andover, MA.

Gramly, Richard Michael and Robert E. Funk
1990Amateur Archaeologist Journal
What is known and not known about the human occupation of the Northeastern United States until 10,000 B.P. Archaeology of Eastern North America 18: 5-32.

Lowery, Jim, Ken Fischer, and Bill Tippins
2007Amateur Archaeologist Journal
Site 36WH59, Washington County Paleoindian fluted projectile point. Pennsylvania Archaeologist 77(2): 28.

Walley, David
2010Amateur Archaeologist Journal
Personal communication: Results of using an IR Raman Laser, Archeoscope Diode, Propietary Laser Microscope system on the Zylo Clovis point.

Figures and Captions


Figure 1. Principal towns and highways near find-spot of Clovis point on the Moore family farm (arrow).

Jump Back

Figures 2. Find-spot of Clovis point in relation to Cross Creek and secondary roads.

Jump Back

Figure 3. The Zylo Clovis point. Length = 111 mm (4 3/8 inches). Note outrepasse flaking. The nick along one edge towards the tip is ancient. Steve Wallmann illustration.

Jump Back


Figures 4. and 5. Photographs of both faces of the Zylo point. Note prominent joint through the stone cutting the channel flake scars.
Amateur Archaeologist JournalFor comparison a complete Clovis point from the Big Bone site near Big Bone Lick, Boone Co., Kentucky is shown alongside the Zylo specimen.

Jump Back

Figure 6. Photograph (looking north) across the narrow floodplain of Cross Creek, which flows at the base of the embankment for Lynn Portal Road. The location of our October, 2010, archaeological testing upon the cultivated terrace is marked by the arrow. Jim Krajacic photograph, April, 2010.

Jump Back

Figures 7. Views of a probable Palaeo-American graver of black chert recovered at the find-spot of the Zylo Clovis point. Steve Wallmann illustration. Length of graver = 37 mm (about 1 1/2 inches). Arrow indicates retouched tip of graver.

Jump Back



Amateur Archaeologist Online Journal
The Amateur Archaeologist welcomes articles and communications from members; please note that authors waive any claim to copyright if they submit materials for publishing in the Society's journal.

Advertisers are welcome, and they need not be members of the ASAA. Please write for advertising rate cards and specifications. The Society does not furnish its membership list to anyone or any organization for promotional mailings.